Sa Sa to exit Singapore as Hong Kong protests, dwindling mainland tourists crush retail sales

By Lam Ka-sing / | December 4, 2019 1:45 PM SGT
Sa Sa International, Hong Kong's biggest cosmetics retailer, will close all its 22 stores in Singapore and cut 170 jobs to save costs as it struggles to stem six years of losses, months of anti-government protests, and the US-China trade war.
Attempts to boost sales in recent years by restructuring the local management team and enhancing store display and product mix have been "far from satisfactory," chairman and chief executive Simon Kwok Siu-ming said in a filing to the stock exchange on Monday. The terminated employees will be compensated according to local employment laws, he added.
Sales in Singapore fell 4.6 per cent to HK$99.4 million (US$12.7 million) in the six months to September 30, the company said, representing 2.8 per cent of the group turnover. At the group level, Sa Sa incurred a HK$36.53 million loss in the period.
Months of protests have hurt Hong Kong's retailers. Photo: Sam Tsang alt=Months of protests have hurt Hong Kong's retailers. Photo: Sam Tsang
"The performance in Singapore has been less than satisfactory for many years, and has recorded losses for six consecutive years," Kwok said in the filing. "It has decided to close all retail stores in Singapore to concentrate its resources on the markets in Hong Kong and Macau, mainland China and Malaysia, as well as its e-commerce business."
The 22 stores will be closed as early as possible but the exact timing will depend on negotiations with individual landlords," he said.
The decision to withdraw from the Southeast Asian city suggests the cosmetics chain is conserving its resources for tougher times at home as months of anti-government protests triggered a slump in tourist arrivals from mainland China, a lifeblood of local retailing industry. Hong Kong's retail sales plummeted 24.3 per cent in October, the biggest monthly decline on record, the government said on Monday.
Visitor arrivals plunged by 43.7 per cent on year in October to 3.31 million, the Hong Kong Tourism Board said. Provisional figures in the first half of November were down more than 50 per cent, according to the Commerce and Economic Development Bureau.
"The double whammy of escalating social unrest across the city and the protracted US-China trade war has resulted in falling retail sales," said David Ji, head of research and consultancy of Greater China at Knight Frank. "There have been waves of shutdowns and lay-offs at retailers. The situation appears to be as bad as during the Asian financial crisis."
Sa Sa did not explain how it has been losing money in Singapore. Apart of the need to "stabilise the management team," the cosmetics chain may have struggled with its focus on neighbourhood malls when shoppers are buying from online stores and retail sales have shrunk every month this year since January.
"Singaporeans, particularly the millennials, like to purchase cosmetic products online from platforms such as Sephora, Lazada, Shopee and evening niche make-up websites," said Christine Li, head of research for Singapore and Southeast Asia at Cushman& Wakefield. "There are also many competitors in the physical space," putting bricks and mortar stores like Sa Sa's under pressure in an economy facing a slowdown, she added.
In its core market in Hong Kong, the operating environment has become extremely difficult due to a drastic decline in mainland tourist arrivals, Kwok said. The primary goal is to focus resources on its core markets and areas with growth potentials to restore profitability, he added.
Sa Sa has failed to build a profitable business in Singapore and is focusing on its Hong Kong stores. Photo: Dickson Lee alt=Sa Sa has failed to build a profitable business in Singapore and is focusing on its Hong Kong stores. Photo: Dickson Lee
Sa Sa's shares have lost 24 per cent in Hong Kong since the beginning of June as anti-government street protests unfolded, erasing HK$1.5 billion of its market value. On year to date basis, the shares have fallen by 43 per cent. Sa Sa is not alone as Hong Kong's economy fell into a technical recession. Industry peers from luxury store owner Dickson Concepts to jeweller Chow Tai Fook and snack-chain operator Best Mart 360 have taken a beating as protests kept visitors away from shopping malls.
Lin Tsz-fung, chairman and founder of Best Mart 360, wants to reduce his reliance on Hong Kong for growth in favour of opening more stores in mainland China after some three-quarters of its 102 stores in the city were vandalised throughout the social unrest.
Some of the stores have been repeatedly thrashed even after restoration, because of the group's alleged links to mainland political bodies. Lin has not dared to open a store planned for October, running down the lease at a loss, he said.
Dickson Concepts, which runs the Harvey Nichols department stores, said sales have been affected while margins squeezed by attempts to move on unsold stocks while fixed costs remain elevated. It does not expect a return of Asian and mainland Chinese tourists in the foreseeable future.
"The group is extremely pessimistic about the retail climate in Hong Kong," founder and group executive chairman Dickson Poon said in a filing to the stock exchange, saying the second fiscal half could be significantly worse. "With Hong Kong in recession, the future looks bleak."
Falling sales at Chow Tai Fook has also prompted the world's largest listed jeweller to take some drastic actions. It will close up to 16 outlets in Hong Kong and is seeking 20 to 50 per cent reduction in rents from landlords when renewing leases from October to March next year.
The group reported a 48 per cent plunge in same-store sales in Hong Kong and Macau in the October 1 to November 21 period. Luk Fook, another jeweller, is also planning to close down outlets in areas worst hit by violent protests.
This article originally appeared in the South China Morning Post (SCMP), the most authoritative voice reporting on China and Asia for more than a century. For more SCMP stories, please explore the SCMP app or visit the SCMP's Facebook and Twitter pages. Copyright © 2019 South China Morning Post Publishers Ltd. All rights reserved.
Copyright (c) 2019. South China Morning Post Publishers Ltd. All rights reserved.